Blog +

How to Avoid Being the Incumbent in a Review

by Meghan McDonnell, Wednesday, September 23, 2015

Does anyone really want to be the incumbent in a review?

Meghan shares six ways agencies can keep their client relationships in good stead, and maybe even keep themselves out of a review. 

Check it out in Ad Age.

How to Make Your Next Client-Agency Meeting a Home Run

by Judy Neer, Thursday, July 09, 2015

There are few things better than a home-run meeting between a client and agency. In advertising at least.

Check out Judy's Ad Age article on the four questions to ask to help ensure the success of your next meeting.


by Judy Neer, Wednesday, May 27, 2015

Is my relationship with the agency strong? Am I getting what I paid for?

At any point in a client/agency partnership, a client should be able to ask these two questions and quickly ascertain the state and health of their relationship. Seems simple enough. The caveat, of course, is that answering these questions requires goals and objectives. Goals and objectives established at the start of the relationship, and then actively managed after the pitch is over. 

In our work with clients and agencies on agency search and performance evaluation, we’ve found that the absence of clear, mutually agreed upon benchmarks is often at the center of strained partnerships. Because in the thick of the day-to-day business, questions arise:

  • Is the agency team overstaffed or understaffed?
  • Is the creative fresh?
  • What constitutes a campaign “win?”
  • How is the agency being measured relative to our corporate goals?
  • Are we productive and efficient?

And without clearly defined objectives, these questions can yield a variety of answers depending on whom you ask, or perhaps even worse, remain unanswered.

With today’s marketing pressures and the rise of procurement’s role in agency management, confirming objectives for both the relationship and investment sides of your client/agency partnership is critical. Great relationships are built on trust—trust that is earned by delivering against your promises. So instead of being stumped by the questions above, consider the following:

  • Alignment of agency compensation with client business goals
  • Creative briefing best practices to avoid multiple changes due to lack of understanding around assignments 
  • A sound contact strategy to quell frustration and confusion around client/agency communication

These are just a few examples. Expectations around brand metrics, sales metrics, media value delivery and market share can also be in the mix. Specific measures will vary from one partnership to another. The larger point is that no one should assume both parties understand where they need to go, how they are being measured and what success looks like without a roadmap. And if procurement is involved, tap them early. Engaging procurement after an agency has been chosen can lead to retrofitted solutions, and disputes between clients and agencies that didn’t need to occur.

The tenure of client/agency partnerships is shrinking. Agency reviews, while at times necessary, are costly and disruptive. Taking the time to solidify relationship and investment goals from the start, and benchmarking against them once the agency is selected, avoids unnecessary reviews, motivates teams on both sides and fosters longer, more valuable partnerships.

This post is co-authored by Judy Neer and Dan Jeffries. Judy is President and CEO of Pile and Company. Dan is a Senior Commercial Consultant in the marketing and advertising space and a Pile and Company partner. 

Visit to learn more about how we help clients in the areas of agency search and performance evaluation.

Is Your Next CMO A Fixer, Maintainer or Builder?

by Christine Hickey, Thursday, May 14, 2015

Most CMO searches begin with a job description—a robust list of requirements around background, skills and capabilities. However, a traditional job spec doesn’t always capture your company’s goals, team and culture. Knowing what kind of CMO your company needs based on specific objectives and challenges is just as important as knowing a candidate’s prior employers or experience. 

Before you embark on your next CMO search, ask and answer the following question— Which type of leader would best fit the goals of our organization?


Are Holding Companies Important in Agency Reviews?

by Meghan McDonnell, Wednesday, April 15, 2015

Believe it or not, we’re asked quite often about whether or not holding companies are important to clients in a review process.

The truth is many clients ask about, but don't really consider, the holding company when selecting a new agency partner.

In the creative reviews we manage, we go to individual agencies when building and recommending our list of agencies—not the holding company.

For media, it’s a little different. In many cases, there is less competition between holding company agencies, and as such, the holding company will often pick only one to go after the business.

The bottom line is that the holding company doesn’t matter as much to clients as some agencies might think. Put forth your best individual agency solutions and you will, in turn, put your best foot forward in a review.

Post Archive

Subscribe to The Brief +

Pile and Company provides agency search, agency performance evaluation, agency compensation, organizational consulting and executive search to global and national marketers.

Contact Us
© 1987-2015 Pile and Company, Inc.